Council here has defeated a proposal from its parks, culture and recreation committee to make all township parks smoke free – but it was not unanimous and the issue will return for more debate.
Councillor Neil Driscoll moved that council support the recommendation, but said the township needs a report from the county. He was referring to the county’s anti-smoking bylaw, which sets distances away from buildings within which people cannot smoke.
Councillor Andy Knetsch seconded Driscoll’s motion to make township parks smoke free.
But Mayor Bruce Whale wondered, “Can we do that?”
Driscoll said he wants a report that states, “This is the separation” from smokers and building entrances.
Councillor Jim Curry said the Maryborough Terrace property recently declared itself to be smoke free, and the whole property has that designation.
Councillor Mike Downey asked, “Who is responsible for enforcement?”
Public Works Director Larry Lynch pointed out Wallace Cumming Park in Alma is about 25 acres, and wondered if someone stands in the middle of it, would he be forbidden to smoke?
Curry said, “Yes.”
Lynch said if staff have to enforce such a rule it would be “impossible.”
Chief Administrative Officer Patty Sinnamon said the township can set distance limits for smokers.
Lynch said he has seen ashtrays at various public buildings moved away from entrances, and people cannot smoke near those any more.
Downey said signs can be posted at the arena stating there is no smoking within 30 metres of the door.
Driscoll said that is what the committee was looking for with its recommendation.
Knetsch said he supports some signs, but he too wondered how the new rule will be enforced.
Whale said, “I’m not sure we can approve it until we know what we can put in place.” He said council can “check possibilities.”
Downey said the OPP can enforce the rules under the county bylaw.
But Sinnamon and Finance Director Mike Givens said it is Wellington-Dufferin-Guelph Public Health that would have to enforce the rule.
Knetsch told council, “The police will not get involved.”
He suggested it might be the territory of the bylaw enforcement officer.
Council then had to vote on the motion, and it was defeated, with only Curry in favour.
Whale said staff can review the issue and bring a report to council.
