Today's date: Thursday June 21, 2018
column width padding column width padding

The Wellington Advertiser Masthead Logo

We Cover The County...
40,251 Audited Circulation

WEEKLY POLL   |   Community News   |   EQUINE   |   Schools & Buses

column width padding column width padding

Drones, robots and thinking

by Dave Adsett

Few will argue that innovation makes life easier.

From electricity to the automobile to mechanized manufacturing processes, our lives are much simpler than what was experienced by previous generations.

Computers, the internet, nuclear energy, super-glue, epi-pens and duct tape were brought to light by military innovators.

The irony of that point is not lost on us. Organizations given a mandate to protect yet kill when required, hardly seem to be the wisest incubators for mankind’s latest inventions. But they are.

The point has been debated for decades, with those questioning the status quo often written off by hawkish politicians as left-wing radicals running amok and playing on the public’s fears. Hmmm. We might one day be glad they did.

Our first military drone sighting was in Washington, DC. They come in many sizes and this one on display may have been six or eight feet long, suspended from the ceiling. At the time we were a bit mesmerized by the device, knowing it was great for surveillance but equally capable when it came to firing a missile.

Quickly our imagination drummed up an image of a drone on the horizon and how a more primitive population would view it as a powerful bird of destruction. We remember at the time thinking how unsporting such a weapon is. It even looked sneaky.

Fast forward three years and the New York Times just published an editorial last week in which drones were described in part as a “seductive tool of modern warfare (with) a dark side”.

Through hundreds of strikes, thousands have perished, including villains and innocent bystanders. It seems to us the predatory nature of such devices and the fallout from their deployment makes it pretty easy to make devastating choices, particularly when it doesn’t involve risking personnel in hand to hand combat.

Military brass seem to be gaining some traction with President Donald Trump, claiming that they alone should handle such operations without the level of civil oversight used in the Obama years.

While we agree with the notion that everyone has a job to do, and certainly respect the military and their professionalism, there are reasons to keep the element of sober second thought in the room. A civilian, despite being a politician, may just not have the stomach for dispatching death where innocent people are at risk.

The expansion of artificial intelligence and its application within a military setting makes the absence of final say by a human even more troubling.

Another article, this time in a recent issue of USA Today, explored the current capabilities of robots and cautioned about the use of artificial intelligence to command them.

The very issues humans have, those being issues of morality or ethics, may well present themselves within the logic of how such machines are programmed.  

The cultures or mindset of the programmer cannot help but show up in the pseudo-psyche of these machines. There have been dozens of science fiction movies based on what happens when a machine goes rogue.

The public shouldn’t be blind to that possibility.

Though humans themselves are prone to poor decisions, there is always the chance of redemption or a glimmer of hope that a soul would speak out for the defenseless. That generally is a Hollywood ethos, about good winning over evil, but there is no guaranteed outcome in the real world.

Hopefully decision makers think long and hard before handing the task of protecting humanity to a computer chip.

There is too much at risk.

March 24, 2017


Tell Us What You Think

Login to submit a comment

Comments appearing on this website are the opinion of the comment writer and do not represent the opinion of the Wellington Advertiser. Comments that attack other individuals or are offensive, unsubstantiated or otherwise inappropriate will be removed. You must register or log in in order to post a comment. For more information, read our detailed Comment Policy and Guidelines.




Wellington County

Buzz: current record does not exist


Barrie Hopkins
Barrie Hopkins
Barrie Hopkins
Barrie Hopkins
Bruce Whitestone
Ray Wiseman
Ray Wiseman
Ray Wiseman
Stephen Thorning
Stephen Thorning


Dave Adsett: When youre done ...

Digital Publications

 •  Browse Our Publications
 •  Highland Games 2015 Pictorial Book
 •  Acton Fall Fair
 •  Canada 150 Special Edition
 •  Community Guide
 •  Business Leader
 •  The Community News
 •  CWCC Awards of Excellence
 •  Drayton Fair Book
 •  Digital Flyers
 •  Erin Fall Fair
 •  Estate and Funeral Planning
 •  Fergus Fall Fair
 •  Groves Foundation
 •  Guelph Township Horticultural Society
 •  Fergus Scottish Festival
 •  Inside Wellington Archives
 •  Lions Club Home & Leisure Show
 •  Mapleton Community Guide
 •  Minding Our Business Archives
 •  NEXANS Celebrating 50 Years in Fergus
 •  Purebred Sheep Breeders of Ontario
 •  70th anniversary of D-Day Feature
 •  Equine
 •  Wellington County Plowing Match
 •  Wellington North Guide
 •  Wellington OPP Annual Reports
 •  Wellington Weddings
 •  Wellington Advertiser - Newspaper Week

column width padding column width padding column width padding

The Wellington Advertiser





Digital Publications


Twitter Logo

Free Press News Network Logo